condoHotels
Compared

What it costs · Anywhere

One week in a hotel or an apartment: a couple, a family of four, a group

Three worked examples in round, made-up numbers, showing where the money goes in a week away and why the cheaper nightly rate does not always win once fees and meals are added.

When it mattersBefore you compare two listingsStart hereAdd every fee to the weekly totalHave readyBoth full totals, meal plans, number of beds

The question of whether a hotel or an apartment is cheaper for a week has no single answer, because it depends on who is travelling, how they eat, and how the listing builds its price. What can be shown is how the sum changes as those things change. The three examples below do exactly that, for a couple, a family of four and a group of six friends.

Every figure here is an illustration, not a quote. The numbers are written in plain units rather than a currency, so that 100 units might stand for 100 euros in one city and something quite different in another. The point is the shape of the comparison, not the totals. Real prices vary by city, season, day of the week and how far ahead a stay is booked, and they change constantly. Fees and local taxes vary too, so treat each line as a placeholder for the real figure on the listing in front of you.

How the examples are built

Each example compares two realistic options for seven nights. On the hotel side, the price is a nightly room rate, plus a local tourist tax where one applies, plus the cost of breakfast if it is not included. On the apartment side, the price is a nightly rate, plus a one-off cleaning fee, plus a platform service fee where the stay is booked through a rental site, plus the same tourist tax, plus groceries for the meals eaten at home.

It also helps to know which costs scale with nights and which do not. A room rate grows with every night. A cleaning fee is usually charged once, whether the stay is two nights or ten. A service fee often grows with the booking total. A tourist tax may be charged per person per night, per room per night, or as a share of the price, depending on the place. Those differences explain most of the surprises people meet at the payment screen, and the guide to the fees that appear on rental listings goes through each one in more detail.

A couple: one hotel room or a studio

Take a couple staying seven nights in a mid-range city area. The hotel option is a standard double room at 100 units a night, with breakfast available at 12 units per person per day. The apartment option is a studio nearby at 80 units a night, with a cleaning fee of 60 units and a service fee of 50 units for the week. In this example both pay a tourist tax of 4 units per person per night.

Couple, 7 nights (illustrative units)Hotel roomStudio apartment
Nightly rate x 7700560
Cleaning fee060
Service fee050
Tourist tax5656
Breakfast for two16840 (groceries)
Total924766

On these numbers the studio wins by a fair margin, but notice how much of the gap comes from breakfast. If the couple prefer to eat out every morning anyway, the breakfast line on both sides becomes a café bill and the gap narrows to about 30 units. If the hotel includes breakfast in the rate, the hotel side drops sharply and the two options are almost level.

Now shorten the stay to three nights and the picture changes again. The studio still carries its 60-unit cleaning fee and a service fee, spread over far fewer nights, so its real nightly cost climbs well above its advertised 80 units. For a couple on a short break, the hotel room is often the simpler and similar-priced choice, which is why a separate piece looks at the cases where a hotel still makes more sense.

A family of four: two rooms, a family room or two bedrooms

Families are where the arithmetic tends to swing most clearly, because a hotel often needs two rooms, or a larger family room, to sleep four people comfortably. Here the hotel option is shown both ways: two connecting standard rooms at 100 units each, or one family room at 160 units. The apartment option is a two-bedroom flat at 150 units a night, with a cleaning fee of 90 units and a service fee of 100 units for the week. The tourist tax in this example applies to adults only, at 4 units per adult per night.

Family of four, 7 nights (illustrative units)Two hotel roomsHotel family roomTwo-bedroom apartment
Nightly rate x 7140011201050
Cleaning and service fees00190
Tourist tax (two adults)565656
Breakfast for four33633670 (groceries)
Some evening mealsrestaurantsrestaurants120 (groceries, three nights)
Total before eating out179215121486

The family room and the apartment come out close on the main lines, and the deciding factor is food. A family of four eating every breakfast in a hotel restaurant spends a sizeable sum over a week. The apartment lets them buy cereal, fruit and bread for a fraction of that, and it lets them eat in on the evenings when the children are tired. Those three home evenings in the table replace three restaurant bills, which in many cities would cost far more than the 120 units of groceries.

The family room and the apartment come out close on the main lines, and the deciding factor is food.

Another guide: Holiday homes and villasHoliday apartment, holiday home, villa or cottage: what the words promise

Six friends: three rooms or a three-bedroom house

Groups are where the apartment or house option usually wins most clearly, because a hotel needs a room for every two people, while a house shares one kitchen, one living room and one cleaning fee among everyone. In this example the hotel option is three double rooms at 100 units each. The house option is a three-bedroom holiday home at 240 units a night, with a cleaning fee of 120 units and a service fee of 150 units. The tourist tax is 4 units per person per night on both sides.

Six friends, 7 nights (illustrative units)Three hotel roomsThree-bedroom house
Nightly rate x 721001680
Cleaning fee0120
Service fee0150
Tourist tax168168
Breakfast for six504100 (groceries)
Total27722218
Per person462370

Split six ways, the house saves each person a noticeable amount, and the group gets a shared living space in which to spend evenings together, which three separate hotel rooms cannot offer. The cleaning and service fees, which looked heavy for the couple, almost disappear once they are divided between six people over seven nights.

The house option does carry risks the hotel does not. A group booking may need a larger security deposit, and some hosts and some cities restrict how many guests can stay or forbid parties outright. Noise rules in residential streets can be strict, and a complaint from neighbours can end a stay early. Group bookings may also face tighter cancellation terms, which matters when six people's plans have to line up.

What changes the answer

Across the three examples, a handful of things move the result more than the headline nightly rate does. Seeing them listed makes it easier to rerun the sum for a real trip.

  • Length of stay. One-off fees are spread over more nights on a longer stay, so the apartment gets relatively cheaper each extra night.
  • Breakfast. Whether the hotel includes breakfast can swing a family comparison on its own.
  • Number of beds needed. Every extra hotel room adds a full nightly rate, while an extra bedroom in an apartment usually adds much less.
  • How the tourist tax is charged. Per person, per room and percentage taxes treat groups and families very differently.
  • Season. Hotels and hosts both raise prices at busy times, but not always by the same amount, so a winner in one month may lose in another.
  • Location. A cheaper apartment far from the sights can cost more once daily transport is added.

Running the sum for a real trip

The method is the same whatever the destination. Open the hotel and apartment options side by side and go to the final payment screen on each, where every fee and tax is shown, because the first price on a search page often leaves some out. Write down the total for the full stay, not the nightly rate. Then add breakfast for everyone on the hotel side if it is not included, and a realistic grocery figure on the apartment side.

After that, think about what each option gives that the numbers do not. Space, a kitchen and a washing machine favour the apartment. Daily cleaning, a staffed desk, flexible cancellation and the ease of a short stay favour the hotel. If the totals are within a few per cent of each other, those softer points are usually the better guide. If one option is far cheaper, check that it is not because it is far from everything, or because the listing is missing something that matters, such as a lift for heavy luggage or air conditioning in summer.

Finally, read the cancellation terms on both, since a cheaper rate that cannot be refunded is only cheaper if the trip goes ahead. Prices, fees and tourist taxes change, so whatever the sums show today, recheck them on the city's and the platform's own pages before paying.